Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bettina's avatar

Thought for a minute you'd made a mistake and gone to France for a holiday!

My vote for laughiest out loud this week goes to: "One in-one out? We are the sovereign nation of Great Britain. Not a newsagent’s outside a school."

Expand full comment
Jeremy's avatar

Macron is of course correct when he says that our blind acceptance of almost anyone, with open arms, bags of cash, free accommodation and a black economy just waiting for them, are the reason that these immigrants want to come to Britain.

I think Starmer's "one in, one out" idea is based on the deterrent effect claimed for Rwanda. The supporters of Rwanda always said that we didn't actually have to send lots of people there, because if the illegal immigrants realised that was their fate, they would stop coming. There were some signs of immigrants fleeing to Eire before the election to avoid a one way ticket to Rwanda.

Unfortunately Starmer's plan will not achieve the same result. 50 people is probably less than 5% of the numbers crossing every week, so that's not really a deterrent, particularly as what will happen is that they will simply be on the next boat over, once returned to France. The people smugglers can just give everyone crossing a personal coupon giving them a second crossing for free. The probability of being sent back twice is 5% squared, or 0.25%, and that's no deterrent at all (you are more likely to die trying to cross than be sent back twice).

Expand full comment
42 more comments...

No posts